Neck and Neck
Here’s a rough idea of what Disney and Comcast’s bids for Fox may be worth when dismissing them both back a year to account for health risks that regulators take a hard look at either deal
The caveats here are that Disney’s stock could very well fall or stay flat over the following financial year. It certainly hasn’t been the boulder wizard lately that it’s been in the past. But the fact that Rupert Murdoch, while sort of heading for the depart, still wanted to maintain a stake in Disney tells me that he insures immense quality in the combined corporation. For one thing, the cost synergies alone will be a big raise to Disney’s earnings. And Bob Iger’s strong M& A track record is what has fueled Disney shares in the past.
Disney has a right to equal in a five-business-day opening, and I believe it will contribute some currency to its furnish mix if that’s what it will take to win a shareholder referendum come July. Disney is already six months into this spate and to some degree, both sides have already been talking about it as if it’s in the bag. It’s not, but the Murdochs and Disney both clearly require the consolidation to take place and seem perpetrated. That introduces me back to timing.
Yes, Tuesday’s ruling signaled that we may genuinely be in an anything-goes batch situation. The judge said here U.S. Justice Department failed to meet its burden of proof to show how a vertical consolidation of AT& T and Time Warner–two non-competitors–would be harmful to the industry and shoppers. He said their bystanders were speculating on the future, rather than catering hard exhibit. The DOJ, with egg on its face the coming week, won’t want to lose another big case.
All that said, are you willing to bet that Comcast, the biggest internet provider in the U.S ., will skirt by regulators, and under a capricious administration and chairwoman who once said he’d seek to break up Comcast/ NBCUniversal? I don’t want to make this a dispute of determining whether President Trump’s personal ax-grinding is constructing its road into regulatory liaisons because that belittles an important gossip about how much influence America’s handful of media , telecommunications and technology whales should have. My degree is that it seems awfully risky to expect a Comcast-Fox or Comcast-Disney merger is a slam dunk. One would think the DOJ would be better prepared in the next go-round.
Of course, Comcast contends 😛 TAGEND
” We are also highly self-confident that our proposed transaction will obtain all required regulatory endorsements in a timely fashion and that our transaction is as or more likely to receive regulatory favor than the Disney transaction .”
This bidding war also may not stretch out for too long. Both admirers have restrictions that will splash some cold water on the ego-driven quality of dealmaking. For Disney, while I’ve written that shareholders will give Iger the benefit of the doubt due to his past deal winnings( Pixar, Marvel, Lucasfilm ), he can’t risk overpaying and, in the twilight of his profession, adding to the sad, interminable inventory of megamergers gone wrong.
For Comcast, it comes down to how much indebtednes it can bear. Buying Fox and Sky Plc, the British broadcaster that Fox partially owns and whose fate is also at post in this bid struggle, could establish Comcast the country’s brand-new biggest corporate borrower. Unlike Disney, though, Comcast CEO Brian Roberts can pretty much do what he requires because regardless of what happens, Comcast’s odd essays of incorporation have him ingrained in the company.
On top of all this, Rupert Murdoch is 87 years old. His son James Murdoch, CEO of the Fox parent, seems to want to move on and do something different. They want to get this display on the road.
Comcast could make a silly-expensive, knockout all-cash offer in the end if it misses. But this is Disney’s deal to lose, and it may not need to alter its proposal often to get Fox’s other shareholders on board.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial card or Bloomberg LP and its owners.